Look, the bottom line is, no matter WHAT the case is, I CANNOT allow a game to be reported twice, once by a player and once by his opponent. For example, player A and player B were in a game and someone disconnected, so they both reported for +75/-35. The net result is that they both gained 40 points. This should not be allowed to happen, and yet it is the case in 90% of disputes. So I have to remove someone's win. And the best guess for who to favor is the one who spoke up.
Any other questions?